zpostcode
What is a carry trade? Lucrative to hold, but painful to unwind
Feb 4, 2025 3:05 PM

  

What is a carry trade? Lucrative to hold, but painful to unwind1

  It’s one of the key components of capitalism: Accessing money as cheaply as possible and seeking the highest possible return. Companies issue stock and bonds to investors, then use the money to fund their business enterprises. Banks attract deposits from savers by paying interest, then loan it out at higher rates in the form of mortgages, auto loans, and business loans.

  And some global institutional traders—such as hedge funds, investment banks, and proprietary trading firms—borrow money in low-interest areas of the world such as Japan and Switzerland, then invest in high-yielding (sometimes speculative, and frequently, momentum-driven) areas of the market.

  This strategy is called a carry trade, and although it can be quite lucrative for those who can successfully employ it, fortunes can be lost in the blink of an eye if and when things start to unwind and traders scramble for the exits at the same time.

  What is a carry trade and how does it work?In any country, interest rates are a function of the economics within that country. If the exchange rate fluctuates due to inflation or other economic uncertainties such as civil unrest, drought, or political instability, the market will demand a higher interest rate to compensate. Central banks such as the U.S. Federal Reserve, Bank of Japan (BoJ), or European Central Bank (ECB) set short-term interest rate targets—and may try to influence longer-term rates by buying and holding securities on their balance sheets. 

  In other words, at any given moment, you might see some countries with interest rates near zero and others upward of 8%. Carry traders—again, these are deep-pocketed investors and funds with a cross-border reach—use these interest rate disparities to initiate a four-step carry trade process:

  Borrow in a low-interest country. For the past several decades, Japan has been the lender of choice among carry trade participants. In recent years, several European countries have also offered an enticing risk-reward profile for the carry trade set. Make a foreign exchange (FX) transaction. When you borrow money in one country, you receive its currency. It must be swapped out for the currency in which you plan to invest your borrowed funds. In other words, you’re carrying your money elsewhere (hence the name).Invest in something with a higher expected return. Carry traders often invest where they see momentum—growth stocks, commodities, cryptocurrencies—or even in higher-yielding government bonds in countries such as Brazil or Mexico.    Monitor the position closely and be ready to liquidate. In general, returns are commensurate with risk. So if anything changes—interest rates in the lending country, or the general appetite for risky assets—carry traders must be ready to pull the plug at any time.Why has the yen carry trade been so popular?Although Switzerland, Denmark, and a few other countries have had ultra-low—and, at times, even negative—benchmark interest rates, Japan has been the top carry trade choice for several decades. Why? The short answer: a commitment to low interest rates and currency stability.

  As part of its occupation and restructuring of Japan after World War II, the U.S. helped build Japan into a global manufacturing powerhouse. By the 1980s, Japanese automobile, electronics, and other manufacturing-intensive industries led the world in terms of per capita output. The benchmark Nikkei 225 stock index swelled into a bubble that, when it burst in the early 1990s, sent Japan into a nasty deflationary spiral.

  The BOJ pushed interest rates to zero (the “zero interest rate policy,” or ZIRP), and there they stayed. Because Japan lacks natural resources, its manufacturing advantage came from buying raw materials, efficiently turning them into finished goods, and selling them to the U.S. and other importing nations. To stay competitive, Japan needed to keep its exchange rate low in a process known as “competitive devaluation.” 

  Because of its dependence on export sales, any hint of inflation—which would naturally drive up interest rates and thus the value of the yen—could threaten economic recovery and send prices and interest rates back down. Market watchers gave this phenomenon a name that sounded as though it were straight out of a Dr. Seuss book: the ZIRP trap. 

  The yen carry trade has been supported by a seemingly endless supply of ZIRP-enabled currency to borrow and Japan’s commitment to keeping the currency from rising in order to maintain its export economy. Remember, after a carry trader borrows yen, they sell that yen to buy dollars, pounds, or other currency, depending on where they plan to invest.

  Carry trade riskThere’s an old adage on Wall Street: “Don’t panic. But if you must panic, panic early.” It’s why, even in the era of deposit insurance and a highly regulated financial sector, we still see the occasional run on the bank. 

  It’s also why, in late July and early August 2024, global investors got a quick lesson in the carry trade and what happens when carry traders are forced to liquidate positions. It all started with a small rate hike by the BoJ (from a range below 0.1% to roughly 0.25%) and a promise by the central bank that there would be more hikes to come. The yen shot up nearly 10% versus the dollar and other major currencies. At one point on August 5, Japan’s benchmark Nikkei 225 was down about 20% from the previous day (see figure 1). The mini-panic spilled over into the U.S. and sent stocks to their worst single-day move since the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020.

  

What is a carry trade? Lucrative to hold, but painful to unwind2

  That’s the chief risk of the carry trade—and any trade that’s backed by borrowed money (i.e., leveraged or “on margin”). When Japan’s interest rates (and currency) shot up at the same time markets were crashing, many carry traders found their positions underwater. They needed to sell any asset they could to raise cash for the dreaded margin calls. This reaction exacerbated the already painful sell-off. 

  The bottom lineAs a retail investor, you probably won’t participate in a carry trade—but when big traders are forced to unwind their deals, it can roil global markets, and you’ll want to be ready. Remember, when professional investors need to raise cash in a hurry, they’ll often sell their most liquid assets. And that could mean temporary bargains in some of your favorite stocks.

  Keep your eye out for these occasional blowouts, keep your wish list handy, and be ready to jump when you feel the time is right.

Comments
Welcome to zpostcode comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Recommend >
Arthropleura
  Arthropleura, genus of exceptionally large extinct millipede-like arthropods that thrived from the Viséan Age of the Carboniferous Period to the Asselian Age of the Permian Period (346.7 million to 293.52 million years ago) and are known from their fossilized exoskeletons. Members of Arthropleura are the largest known arthropods in Earth’s history, with an estimated length exceeding 2.6 meters (8.5 feet)—roughly...
lo-fi music
  lo-fi music, genre of music production in which a recording is intentionally rendered to include imperfections, such as harmonic distortion, background noise, or other anomalous sounds. Such irregularities are normally filtered out of professional recordings, since they generally are undesirable. However, some artists have embraced the limitations of low-quality recording, leveraging imperfections as an artistic choice. The term lo-fi is...
American crocodile
     American crocodile (Crocodylus acutus)American crocodiles (Crocodylus acutus) basking in the sun in Costa Rica. Usually solitary, the reptiles bask for most of the day and then enter the water during the evening to hunt.(more)American crocodile, (Crocodylus acutus), moderately large species of crocodile inhabiting forests and freshwater environments, as well as brackish and marine intertidal environments, in Florida, Central America,...
Burmese python
  Burmese python, (Python bivittatus), species of constrictor snake that is native to various environments in southern and Southeast Asia, including several islands in Indonesia, and is known for its exceptional size and its environmental adaptability. Burmese pythons inhabit mangrove forests, rainforests, swamps, grasslands, rivers, and rocky areas, in a range extending from Nepal, Bangladesh, northeastern India, and Myanmar (Burma) eastward...
Information Recommendation
spectacled caiman
  spectacled caiman, (Caiman crocodilus), species of alligator-like reptiles common to swamps, other wetlands, and waterways in Central America and northern South America. The spectacled caiman takes its name from its most prominent distinguishing feature, a bony ridge between the eyes that resembles the nosepiece of a pair of eyeglasses. The species has adapted to a wide variety of habitats, and...
reticulated python
     reticulated python (Malayopython reticulatus)Reticulated python (Malayopython reticulatus) coiling around a branch. One individual of this species of Asian python attained a length of 10 meters (32.8 feet).(more)reticulated python, (Malayopython reticulatus), species of giant constricting snake belonging to the python family, Pythonidae, and known for being the longest living snake in the world, with the largest recorded individual measuring 10...
megamouth shark
     megamouth shark (Megachasma pelagios)Schoolchildren looking into the tooth-lined mouth of a 4.2-meter- (13.8-foot-) long preserved megamouth shark (Megachasma pelagios) specimen at Tokai University Marine Science Museum in Shizuoka, Japan.(more)megamouth shark, (Megachasma pelagios), species of large filter-feeding sharks inhabiting the continental shelf and open-ocean regions of tropical and temperate oceans worldwide. The species is found between latitudes 40° N and...
tarantula hawk
  tarantula hawk, (genus Pepsis), genus of about 130 species of spider wasps that paralyze spiders to feed their larval young. Tarantula hawks are found on every continent except Europe and Antarctica and are especially common in the southwestern United States through Central America. The tarantula hawk’s sting is said to be one of the most painful insect stings in the...
American alligator
  American alligator, (Alligator mississippiensis), species of alligator inhabiting freshwater rivers, lakes, and swamps and brackish waters in the Southern U.S. and northeastern Mexico. The alligator’s geographic range extends from the Mexican states of Coahuila, Nuevo León, and Tamaulipas northeastward to Oklahoma and Arkansas and eastward through the Gulf Coast to North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, and Florida. The species is...
These 8 Buildings Will Make You See Norway in a New Light
      Norway, by some estimates, is two-thirds mountainous, and about half of its population lives in the south of the country, where its capital, Oslo, is located. These eight contemporary buildings will give you another lens through which to see this Scandinavian country.   Earlier versions of the descriptions of these buildings first appeared in 1001 Buildings You Must...
The Largest Islands in the World
      Quite a few islands around the world are very large, and many of them are countries. Australia is technically an island because it is unconnected to any other body of land, but it is more commonly considered a continental landmass. Of the seven continents, Australia is the smallest, at 2,969,976 square miles, or 7,692,202 square kilometers. However,...
Quetzalcoatlus
  Quetzalcoatlus, genus made up of two species of giant pterosaurs classified in the family Azhdarchidae, which contains some of the largest known flying animals. Both species lived during the Maastrichtian Age (72.1 million to 66 million years ago) of the Cretaceous Period. One of them, Quetzalcoatlus northropi, is widely believed to have been the largest flying creature that ever lived....